/m/ - Mecha

Turn A vs Chirico's Scopedog

Scopedog wins somehow.

Mazinkaiser vs. Gaogaigar (not the Genesic version)

Mazinkaiser wins. I'm not trying to troll, I swear. Apparently Fire Blaster can melt anything so...yeah...

Believe me, if it was Genesic Gaogaigar, much Courage-based hax would ensue.

My favorites are so obscure I can't find stats on them.

Zinv vs Dai-Guard.

RX-78-2 vs basic Eva 01(I only like it when it's not doing weird shit.)

This battle goes to Gundam's superior firepower and agility.

>>4077177
Zinv walks into the area, Dai-Guard falls apart. Part of the reason is because Zinv controls gravity.

Great Exkaiser vs. Grungust Type-3

Sorry Grungust, but you're considered a disposable unit by Banpresto...

Cybuster vs Crossbone X3

I would state a winner, but seeing how Ken Ando will never ever even get to the right battle grounds at the right time.....

>>4077318
>Ken Ando
......I, uh... I'm not comfortable, for some reason.

>>4077244
>Robot that controls gravity

I am very interested now. Also, second matchup from me:

Kotetsu Jeeg vs. King Gainer

It's close but King Gainer wins, but is probably heavily damaged.

>>4077177
Zinv by a longshot.

That being said Dual! is awesome.

F91 vs Crossbone

Well that answer's pretty obvious

VF-0S vs Freedom Gundam

Freedom hands down. Kira would mop the floor with Roy in a VF-0S unfortunately. Its sad but eh oh well

I was looking through my old folders when I ran across this, I have no idea how this could go.

I got it off /m/ a long time ago.

>>4077345
>>4077244

Point. And DaiGuard tends to fall apart without help.

Z-01 Lancelot (vanilla version)

-vs-

VF-22S

The Sturmvogel would rape the shit out of Lancelot or any KMF.

Harlock's Arcadia vs. The Yamato.

Harlock appears to steal an easy victory immediately, but at the end of the episode they fire the Wave-Motion Gun.

MazinKaiser vs Shin Getter 1
they world is destroyed during the fight, the clash of photonic energy and getter energy being to much for the earth to handle the battle is taken to space.
I say Kaiser wins because i have never seen it take a beating, is armor is too damn much and fire power is supreme.

>>4077830
Shin Getter absorbs Mazinkaiser. End of battle.

Good job at ignoring abilities.

ITT: people who feel the mech determines the battle rather than the pilot.

But here's one anyway.
Jehuty vs Epyon

I honestly can't tell who would win. Epyon has the Zero System so it can calculate Jehuty's moves, however Jehuty is so much faster that I would think Epyon would be in some shit. Either way, it depends on who's piloting both.

VF-1 vs Big-O

VF-1, being uber fast compare to the sluggish Big-O, has a definite advantage, plus the missile spam doesn't hurt. However, I'm sure Big-O can shrug off that missiles without a problem with its thick armor and try to bring it down with his O-Thunder, Moby Dick Anchor, or his Chromebuster. BUT, VF-1 being much much smaller than the towering Big-O, he's going to have a hard time getting a solid hit...

Man, this is hard to decide...

Guaiz vs. Gespenst Mk II

Guaiz has superior raw performance, but the Gespenst has a more varied arsenal and doesn't have to worry about battery life. I'd give it to the Guaiz 6 times out of 10, probably, giving it a sliiight advantage due to just being faster and its solid weaponry all around.

Note that this is in space; Gespy probably wins on Earth.

>>4077874
Non-MP Gespensts would like to have a word with you.

Getter Emperor vs Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagaan.

Winner: Getter emperor.

>>4077382
Not sure how this would go ether... the Strike Freedom definitely has superior armor and firepower, but it isn't going to make much a difference against something with the maneuverability of the X-9.
I think it comes down to Strike Freedom's pilot (who I assume is Kira) and the X-9s AI. I would honestly say it would end up a draw, ending up with the destruction of both units, similar to a certain other fight with the X-9...

>>4077879
Let's specify MP Gespies then.

For sanity's sake.

...Kai in his Custom Gespenst beats any SEED grunt. Same for Gilliam and the RV.

>>4077889
I get the feeling this would be an eternal stalemate.

Epyon VS GINN

Epyon probably has a newtype/zero system hax plotarmor pilot, so it cuts the GINN in half without actually making contact

But whatever, GINNs are still beautiful

Getter Emperor vs. Ginguiser

Winner:
Ginguiser

GAT-X370 Raider Gundam VS XXXG-01H2 Gundam Heavyarms Kai

Based on Trowa's tendency to run out of bullets, and Clotho's tendency to run out of power, this should devolve into a brutal melee fight if Raider doesn't bitch out and fly circles around Heavyarms shooting mouth beams.

Flail VS gundanium army knife, go!

F91 vs GP03 Dendrobium

Not really a contest here, Kou is a fucking useless pilot at the best of times against a huge Gundam, so a tiny little thing with afterimages piloted by a Newtype will fuck him up.

The only way the GP03 could win is by hitting the F91 with saturation missile fire as it approaches, but even then the F91 has a beam shield, or could use its sabers as beam rotors as it did to beat the BUGs.

>>4077964
>Kou is a fucking useless pilot at the best of times against a huge Gundam
Eat a dick.

>>4077991
To be fair, he is one of the least skilled Gundam protagonists.

King Gainer vs Turn A

Well this is a toughy. Series Turn A only, Gainer wins. Controlling temperature and thus time is one of the most powerful abilities ever. he could freeze the air around Turn A to the point that Moonlight Butterfly ceases to be able to move. Then OVERHEAT.

>>4077991
Let's see...

Oldtype
Fails pretty much every mission he attempts

vs

Seabook

Newtype
Surprisingly talented

>>4078011
Hell I'm not even sure extended material Turn A would fare much better. It has a ton of crazy abilities, but it won't matter if it is frozen.

>>4077843
wtf are talking about? absorb? is that from the fucking manga? fucking stupid

>>4078055
>wtf

>>4078055
It's a little like how your asshole absorbs your buddies' balls.

Except the Getter isn't gay.

Ginguiser vs. TTGL

Winner:
Ginguiser

Gelgoog vs. Dragonzord

Probably the Dragonzord. It's bigger than a Gelgoog and probably wouldn't even flinch at the Gelgoog's beam rifle. Compared to some of that crap the Dragonzord's taken, a small beam rifle probably won't do much.

Zeta Gundam vs Destiny Gundam
Due to the fact that most of the Zeta's weapons are defended against it would have to go melee.
And it would win, because 2x beam sabers > 1 slow large sword.
This is exactly why it lost to the ∞ Justice.
This is not even taking into account crazy newtype hax.

>>4077843
Kouji is more hot-blooded than Ryouma.
Getter kicks the team out and grafts itself to Mazinkaiser becoming Shinkaiser-1

>>4078055
Uh... Shin Getter originates from the manga cannon. The OVAs are just side stories.

>>4078177
Not how it works. Shin Getter has absorbed things which are bigger, and more powerful than itself before, and still ends up on top.
>You must post the result based solely on stats and not favoritism.
I suggest you read Getter Robo Go.

>>4078171

what happens when he pops

SEED MODE

????????????

>>4078177
Ryouma isn't even the pilot of Shin Getter-1. And it's not about being hot-blooded. They're completely calm.

Ideon Vs Zearth

Winner:Zeath,towering over Ideon and has more beam then ideon has weapons

>>4078374
Correct me if I'm mistaken but doesn't Ideon have a black hole gun?

Astro Boy - Demonbane
Astro Boy wins, he has A MILLION FUCKING HORSEPOWER

>>4078374
Every single part of Zearth(as in every place you can aknowlegd to exist) is capable of shooting overpowered laser that can end anyone day

>>4078407
Also there is that thing tha Idean power can go to infinite over time,but Zearth has his power frezed in infinite

Steel Jeeg vs. Jehuty

Jehuty wins apparently because it's designed to detonate to defeat it's enemy (originally for Auuman). Both would die in this case but it's still technically Jehuty's win because it was the the mech's programming to do so in the first place.

Megaman Vs Ultraman
Megaman wins because he copies Ultraman's big

Kampfer vs Gouf Custom

I'll give it to the Kampfer as long as it stays at a range.

>>4078484

Laughing Norris laughs at you

HE REALLY KNOWS HOW TO USE A MOBILE SUIT!

>>4078333
But Ryouma is the pilot. In fact he pilots it in every manga and anime the mech appears in. not only that but its at it's strongest when he is aboard it. oh and Shin Getter evolves into Getter Emperor by absorbing everything. that ability is very much canon. And by the way you would be hard pressed to find something to beat Getter Emperor when while still the size of planets the Eagle had the potential energy to create the big bang. try thinking of a mech that can deal with it when it absorbs the entire universe.

>>4078390
But that's only in the World's Strongest Robot arc.

But that's also the arc that gave us Pluto, so... go on.

>>4078177

Anyone have the page where Getter 2 drills a hole into the Mazinger's cockpit?

>>4079284
Ryouma doesn't pilot Shin Getter-1 when it reaches full power. Go is the one to dominately fuse with Shin Getter in Getter Robo Go.

Though, Ryouma and Tayel are still very important. As for Emperor, yes, that was described to be mainly Ryouma. Though, there is little info on Emperor and it's inner workings, as Ryouma is never even shown physically. Emperor should theoretically consisist of the same team as full power Shin Getter, but who knows.

>And by the way you would be hard pressed to find something to beat Getter Emperor

Well, that's pretty unrelated to the rest of the post. You should be a bit more coherent.

>>4079284
>try thinking of a mech that can deal with it when it absorbs the entire universe.
Obligatory Demonbane post.

>>4079311

The one where the blood spews out to make sure you know the pilot died? I heard it was some girl in the cockpit and not Koji.

>>4079284 oh and Shin Getter evolves into Getter Emperor by absorbing everything.

Speculation, not fact.

AV-98 Ingram vs. ATM-09-ST Scopedog

This one's tricky to call, The Scopedog is faster but the Ingram has thicker armour. Their armaments are comparable in strength (37mm Revolver Cannon vs. 30mm Heavy Machine Gun) and both pilots (Chirico and Noa) are skilled at making tactics up on the spot.

The Scopedog can use it's speed and agility to evade the Ingram's shots and when the Ingram's out of Ammo (the revolver cannon only has 6 shots) Chirico can rush in and arm punch the knees out. Alphonse is then a sitting duck and can be hit from behind with everything the Scopedog's got.
BUT, knowing Noa, she'd throw the revolver cannon away after realising she won't hit anything and would instead close with the stun baton. With the Ingram's reach, if she lands a hit, the Scopedog would be disabled. Then again, Chirico is not that bad in infantry vs. Mech combat.

If I had to call it, I'd go with the Scopedog because of it's speed and agility.

>>4077857
>>ITT: people who feel the mech determines the battle rather than the pilot.

Well, pilot skills can only do so much against a superior mech. Take one of Gundam Wing's Leos: That thing is so fucking obsolete that even if you put a badass pilot like Heero it would not stand a chance... wait.

Ok, take the Ball. It's a bubble with a bun, the most fucking stupid thing to keep producing during the OYW. There's no way anyone in it can take on a mobile - - damn.

I got nothing.

>>4077996
>To be fair, he is one of the least skilled Gundam protagonists.
...He pushed the GP-01 past it's expectations on his first goddamn sortie and agianst the goddamn Nightmare of Solomon!

>>4079325
man I really want to read Getter Robo Go but the faces look so fucking terrible it always puts me off. Does the art get better later on or is it always so abysmal?

It's weird, because the actions seens and the mecha always look awesome, but the dude just cannot draw a regular, nondeformed face to save his life.

>>4079408
Ball is god tie, faggot.

http://www.mangafox.com/manga/crossbone_gundam_skullheart/v01/c001/

>>4079436
*tier

>>4079423
So? That's not amazing compared to some other Gundam leads. How about Shiro's invinciball? Aimbot Yamato? GN-Fuelled Setsuna? Kamille, Amuro or Judau's LOL NEWTYPE MAGIC?
Kou doesn't have enough plothax to be considered anything but a lowtier Gundam pilot, alas.

RX-78-2 Gundam vs. Nirvash typeZERO specs1

Winner is the white one.

>>4079427
The art's great. Your loss.

>>4079468
it's just the faces, man. everything else about the art ranges from tolerable to awesome but every face i've seen from that manga looks like some kind of fucked up mutant

>>4079477
You didn't watch Escaflowne due to the noses too, didn't you?

>>4079477
Once again. Your loss.

>>4079477
The faces are the best thing though.

Doraemon versus Gaogaigar:

Doraemon wins.

Fuck being powered by courage, the forth wall is Doraemon's bitch.

>>4079486

The noses became fine after about half way through when Van becomes a killing machine.

Demonbane vs. Alternity Convoy

Alternity Convoy comes out on top. Both have abilities that put time and space, even dimensions in danger.
Alternity Convoy however, has a mechanism designed to pinpoint and predict such activity, and the ability to erase himself from existence and re-appear at will.

>>4079477
>>4079427
...and why do you watch anime?

They all look like mutants with terrible proportions. Especially mainstream anime.

I love Ishikawa's expressions, but not the actual faces themselves. He's best at drawing intentionally ugly/goofy people, which is usually everyone except the main cast.

>>4077843
>>4077830
The fact Shin Getter's roughly twice Mazinkaiser's height probably helps too...

>>4079345

It was Brocken

>>4079522
Depends on the source.

Manga Shin Getter isn't that big compared to the OVAs sizes. In fact, the anime versions of all the Getters are always like 2-3 times bigger than the manga counterparts.

Outside of the OVA's, hotbloodedness actually isn't much of a factor in Getter Robo. In fact, the pilots pretty much meditate to become one with Shin Getter.

>>4079547 In fact, the pilots pretty much meditate to become one with Shin Getter.

Truth.

They're not hot-blooded in the way that Gai or Kouji is, they're probably closer to "mentally unstable" seeing their readiness to kamikaze attack or get excited piloting a death machine with enough G's to make someone regurgitate their guts. You know, like real test pilots.

>>4079547
that is pretty true in Getter Robo Go Ryouma almost seems like a normal person

>>4079617
>normal person
>snapping a katana with his chest muscles

Getter Robo pretty much treats it's characters like 80s American action heroes. Sure, they eat grenades and shit katanas, and run around smashing dinosaur skulls with their bare hands, but when it comes to the actual fights, screaming and shouting isn't what decides the battle. That's where pseudo-science comes in and takes over!

Speaking of getter anyone got the FUCK DINOSAURS! page?

>>4079812

System Id Alpha Weltall vs. Escaflowne

Weltall, despite Escaflowne's CLAW CLAW BITE WING BUFFET dragon form.

>>4077216
>ignoring the AT field

>>4080057
Evas 1-3 has a huge flaw. Once the cable's cut they only have five minutes to accomplish a mission. With Gundam's agility it can just wait for that time to pass then finish it off when it's no longer operational.

Ryujinmaru vs Nu Gundam.

Ryujinmaru battled against odd even greater than Amuro's final battle. I think we know who the obvious winner is.

Sorry Amuro... NT skills just doesn't quite add up to the amount of plot armor the main character in a typical 90's kid mecha show has.

>>4080167
yeah it's not like the eva 1 was ever operational after losing power. you are also forgetting about the N2 unit 1 ate and you are reall under estimataing the movement and size of eva as well. Rx-78 would be lunch for the eva 1

>Shin Getter absorbing things
Picture related

>>4080568
lol wut? wouldn't that explode within

>>4080581
Nope.