[ a / cgl / jp / m / tg ] [ index / top / reports / report a bug / questions ]

/jp/ - NEET & Hikikomori/General


View post   

File: 83 KB, 396x400, 1218267280349.jpg [View same] [iqdb]
1513993 No.1513993 [Reply] [Original]

FSN animu > Tsukihime animu

Discuss.

>> No.1513994

/thread, nothing to discuss.

>> No.1513996

Something is always better than nothing.

>> No.1513997

You're right, FSN had a superior anime, because Tsukihime didn't have one.

>> No.1513998

Sakura > Every other Nasu girl

>> No.1513999

OP is right

everybody go back to your VNs

>> No.1514004
File: 220 KB, 548x442, 1225042834919.png [View same] [iqdb]
1514004

>>1513998
MAGARE

>> No.1514012
File: 321 KB, 710x1065, 1225042939098.jpg [View same] [iqdb]
1514012

Ths FSN anime had no manfaces, unlike the Tsukihime anime.

>> No.1514016

Tsukihime anime had a great soundtrack.

>> No.1514024
File: 68 KB, 786x480, 1225043093200.jpg [View same] [iqdb]
1514024

>>1514012
The Tsukihime animu didn't have Shirou.

>> No.1514044
File: 144 KB, 304x447, 1225043481899.png [View same] [iqdb]
1514044

>>1514024
It had Shiki

>> No.1514084

>>1514012
>manfaces
You started watching animu in 2005,right?

>> No.1514088

>>1514004
that kanji sir, is wrong

>> No.1514103
File: 64 KB, 450x619, 1225044127450.jpg [View same] [iqdb]
1514103

>>1514044
I meant the no Shirou thing as a plus, not a negative.

>> No.1514104

Tsukihime (not) anime = Arc story concentred in 13 eps
Fate stay night = Saber story diluted in 24 eps

>> No.1514112

>>1514104
Don't forget the Caster arc from UBW route was thrown in for kicks.

>> No.1514117

>>1514084
I started watching in the 80s

Shit has change so much!

>> No.1514118
File: 64 KB, 546x900, 1225044415572.jpg [View same] [iqdb]
1514118

>>1514112
Also, the climax of heaven's feel.

>> No.1514125
File: 62 KB, 640x480, 1225044501377.jpg [View same] [iqdb]
1514125

>>1514118
>climax of HF
Funny, I don't see a GOD DAMN FIST FIGHT BETWEEN SHIROU AND KOTOMINE IT'S LIKE THE MOTHERFUCKING FIST OF THE NORTH STAR HOLY SHIT anywhere.

>> No.1514126

>>1514112
In Tsukihime faux-animu there was some elements from the tohno household and Ciel story.

>> No.1514137

>>1514118
she needs a whip

>> No.1514157
File: 981 KB, 708x1594, 1225045214995.png [View same] [iqdb]
1514157

>>1514137

>> No.1514164

OP is wrong.
The anime of Tsukihime had a good atmosphere, a great soundtrack and a romance that was "believable" and well developed.
The anime of FSN was fucking shitty from the beginning to the end.
Only the worst TM faggots could disagree.

>> No.1514177
File: 13 KB, 350x450, 1225045748972.gif [View same] [iqdb]
1514177

>>1514164
But.. the manfaces..

>> No.1514178
File: 106 KB, 554x439, 1225045762534.jpg [View same] [iqdb]
1514178

>>1514164
>The anime of Tsukihime had a good atmosphere

WHY WOULD ARCUEID RUN FROM A GUY WITH A KNIFE?

>> No.1514186

>>1514164
Why would a TM fag disagree? It's only the generic-animu obsessed that like the crap FSN turned into.

>> No.1514188
File: 72 KB, 640x480, 1225045939045.jpg [View same] [iqdb]
1514188

>>1514178
Cause he was a guy with a knife that could somehow cut the arm of the fucking princess of True Ancestors?

Maybe?

Poor Arc was so scared...

>> No.1514202

>>1514188
She doesn't know this fact when she bumps into him on the sidewalk. There's no reason she, the most powerful being on the world, would be scared of a high-school boy with a knife.

>> No.1514206

>>1514202
I actually just wanted to post the cute picture, but anyway,

>> No.1514210
File: 46 KB, 800x320, 1225046213727.jpg [View same] [iqdb]
1514210

At least Shiki banged manface Arc.

>> No.1514266
File: 26 KB, 704x384, 1225047176857.jpg [View same] [iqdb]
1514266

>>1514210
Gay sex.

>> No.1514331

>>1514266
but sex.

>> No.1514592

>>1514331
yeah

>> No.1514639

The Tsukihime anime was nice because it actually had significant character development, unlike the FSN anime.

The FSN anime is great though if you love Bleach and other shonen fighting anime filled with episodes of pointless power level discussion.

>> No.1514649

>The Tsukihime anime was nice because it actually had significant character development

Shiki is emo, Arcueid's character portrayal is all kinds of wrong, Akiha gets her ass kicked without even doing anything, Ciel is even worse in the anime than she is in the game, and the mAIDS don't do anything.

If anything, the anime gives more attention to Sacchin than it does the maids.

>> No.1514678

>>1514639
>filled with episodes of pointless power level discussion.
I don't think so. There was a lot less power level discussion in the anime than the visual novel, and there sure as hell weren't whole episodes of it. The F/SN anime isn't great but it definitely isn't bad enough to compare it to your average action shonen.

>> No.1514684

>>1514649
Shiki isn't that way by the end of the anime, though. It's significant character development, except just presented differently from the VN. Either way, it's still better than anything in the Fate anime. All your other examples aren't even relevant, and are just fanboy nitpicking.

>> No.1514712

>>1514684
You're missing the point. He's saying that comparatively speaking the Tsukihime anime represented a much greater failure in adapting the source material than Fate. Both represent a decline in quality, but Fate would be the Lord of the Rings movies while Tsukihime would be the Super Mario Brothers movie. Do you contest that the Tsukihime anime was a better adaptation of the source material than Fate?

>> No.1514829

>>1514712
>>but Fate would be the Lord of the Rings movies while Tsukihime would be the Super Mario Brothers movie
No, just no.
The director of the anime of Tsukihime probably realized he couldn't adapt the VN successfully so he tried to do his own things, some failed and some were successful. But as a stand-alone anime it's really not bad at all.
FSN tried to be more "faithful but it resulted in an overall pretty mediocre anime.

>> No.1514839

>>1514829
Thus, we end up with two series that barely pass above average.

And both of them giving birth to some of the most consistent anime memes on the internet.

>> No.1514842

>>1514712
Don't start discussion with failures at VR like tripfags

Fate anime > Tsukihime anime and everybody agreed.
/thread

>> No.1514887

>>1514842
Faggot, go to one of yours retarded forum if you want to have a shitty consensus.

>> No.1514900

When I'm playing Tsukihime I can think of a shit-ton better ways to adapt it to animation. It's not that hard; our film vocabulary over the last century has plenty of good examples to draw from.
These people just don't know how to use their own medium.

>> No.1514923

>>1514900
HURR DURR BY COCKSUCKING TRIPFAGS I CAN CIRCLEJERK MASEEV 1001 INTERNETZ !!!!111!!1!2HU1!1!

>> No.1516145
File: 906 KB, 2096x2180, 1225070355405.jpg [View same] [iqdb]
1516145

how about we forget about Tsukihime and Fate anime and we get into Kara no Kyoukai which is at least done in a much better way than the already named piece of shit?

>> No.1516183

I suppose I can say this with some honesty, since I watched the Tsukihime anime twice years before I even heard it was a game, and played it only recently. The anime itself was a bit of an anomaly when you compare it to other anime in general - the feel was melancholic, and that's all. Literally, all. There's minute changes in pace and presentation, but all in all, it's just an even substance of varying occurrences represented under the same emotional charge. The anime made a lasting impression through being emotionally single-tracked rather than anything else, really, which is hardly what the original piece was.

Also, Akiha > Sakura. Faget.

>> No.1516186

>>1516145

GOOD KOKUTO YOU LOOK EXACTLY LIKE SHIKI

>> No.1516204

THE ONLY GOOD EXAMPLES OF TYPE MOON GAMES TO ANIME ADAPTATIONS ARE the
Kara no Kyoukai movies AND 428 the animation (HOPEFULLY)

http://myanimelist.net/anime/5356/428_the_animation

shit looks awesome and nothing is written about it yet

>> No.1516212

>>1516204

They didn't even release the game yet and there's already an anime adaptation in the works? Nasu wastes no time these days; message could learn a thing or two from him.

>> No.1516213

Who else thinks the Kara no Kyoukai movies are better than the novels? Because I do. And you can't convince me otherwise. Faggots.

>> No.1516221

>>1516213
I agree. I like you. Want to hang out sometime?

Maybe marathon the 3 KnK movies together? Or watch the 4th when it comes out together?

>> No.1516224

>>1516213
different medium

feels the same

excellent adaptations

novel brings back memories
me needs moar movies NOW FAGGET

>> No.1516244

>>1516204
what is this "/428_the_animation" you speak about?

new unreleased Type-Moon game was announced

WHEN?

WHAT?

WHO?

Shibuya?

>> No.1516259

>>1516244
It's not a TM game, they're doing one bonus scenario for it.

>> No.1516286

>>1516259
Any info about the game?

>>
Name (leave empty)
Comment (leave empty)
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Password [?]Password used for file deletion.
Action